WELCOME TO: Outsidethebubble.net ....A centre-left blog with a Scientific leaning.

Outsidethebubble

  • Home
  • Latest Posts
  • Archive
  • Useful Links
  • About
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Home
  • Latest Posts
  • Uncategorized
  • Trident: The Third Way. Make Do and Mend!
18th February 2019

Trident: The Third Way. Make Do and Mend!

admin
Monday, 23 January 2017 / Published in Uncategorized
Trident: The Third Way. Make Do and Mend!

Summary: We need to rethink what we should be doing about Trident, given the recent embarrassing failure. The choice need not be between scrapping Trident and replacing it with a new system at very great expense. The third possibility is to make do with the current system. It only needs to be kept running at a level that makes it a plausible deterrent. This would be dramatically cheaper than building a new submarine system when so many in the UK military feel it is simply not a sensible thing to do.

Calls to scrap Trident altogether or to replace it at great cost ignore the possibility of extending the life of the current Vanguard class Trident submarines.  Their design is based on the US Ohio design but the boats were manufactured in the UK.  Although designed with a 25 year lifetime there is no good reason why the Royal Navy cannot simply make do and mend, replacing any components that cause serious safety concerns.  The US replacement programme has their new submarines entering service 50 years after the Ohio class vessels entered service.  The Trident missiles are not British owned but leased from the US where they are routinely refurbished and repaired.  These missiles will continue to be used by the US replacement submarines.

Unfortunately, the recent failure during a test firing is very concerning. UK submarines have test fired around 10 missiles over the last 20 years. The manufacturers of the missiles, Lockheed Martin, claim very large numbers of firings without incident although the above image, of a Trident II(D5) missile being fired doesn’t look completely right. No doubt government press officers will explain how that might be completely normal. Another Trident malfunction in mid-2015 can be seen at: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xLmB81v-BI .

Trident continues to be reasonably popular with the public and politicians.  Refurbishing the British submarines would preserve jobs while allowing the decision about a replacement to be delayed.  Even in the British military there is increasingly doubt that these Trident systems are militarily relevant.  Trident is hardly an independent nuclear deterrent when the missiles are owned and maintained by the US.  It is inconceivable that the UK could use these without US knowledge and approval.  There is little doubt that keeping the existing Trident fleet going would be a significantly cheaper option in the medium term.

Given that there are almost no circumstances under which we might actually use a nuclear weapon it is difficult to see why an entirely new generation of vessels should be procured anyway.  The obsession with Trident replacement is another example of a military keen to be ready to fight the last war.  Along with aircraft carriers and other large warships, all greatly at risk from a single missile strike, they have little relevance in the 21st-century.  Defence money ought to be directed towards both improving cyber warfare capability as well as the development of fast, manoeuvrable unmanned aircraft.  These would be cheaper and more capable than the eye-wateringly expensive fighter aircraft still being ordered enthusiastically by the military.

Defence policy experts P W Singer & A Cole have written a novel, part fiction and part non-fiction entitled “Ghost Fleet: a Novel of the Next World War” which gives a much more realistic and much more scary idea of what real threats we might have to deal with in the future.  Defence policy must start looking much more to the future.  We must think through very carefully what the country actually needs to keep us all safe in a rapidly changing world.

 

  • Tweet

What you can read next

Time for a new political party?
Summer Is Over: Back to the Salt Mine.
Mt Theresa Close to Eruption.

6 Comments to “ Trident: The Third Way. Make Do and Mend!”

  1. fake gucci belt says :Reply
    1st January 2018 at 23:00

    Hello! I just wish to give you a big thumbs up for the excellent
    info you’ve got right here on this post. I’ll be coming back to your site for more soon. fake gucci belt

  2. Kennith says :Reply
    4th June 2017 at 23:12

    Hi, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog site in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has
    some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, terrific blog! http://www.hmorrison.com/index.php/component/k2/itemlist/user/557724

    1. admin says :Reply
      10th June 2017 at 09:46

      Can’t do much about that! WordPress is a package that cannot be restructured by innocent users. Internet Explorer is no longer the main Microsoft browser, so will be increasingly forgotten. Nevertheless thank you for your positive comments about the blog!

  3. free htaccess password generator says :Reply
    27th January 2017 at 07:56

    You are so awesome! I don’t think I’ve read through something like this before.
    So great to find someone with some unique thoughts on this subject.
    Really.. thank you for starting this up. This site is something that
    is needed on the internet, someone with a bit of originality!

    1. admin says :Reply
      27th January 2017 at 11:48

      Thank you for your kind words! Tell your friends about Outsidethebubble.net, and more important spread the ideas!

  4. Jane says :Reply
    25th January 2017 at 22:29

    I have been surfing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never found
    any interesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for
    me. In my opinion, if all site owners and bloggers made
    good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Posts

  • A Truly Dreadful Night for Labour.

    Summary: Now that most of the election results ...
  • Theresa May and Her Poisonous Immigration Policies.

    Summary: Theresa May in this photograph, taken ...
  • Labour Can Substantially Restrict Freedom of Movement

    Summary: Jeremy Corbyn has clearly stated on a ...
  • Endemic Corruption in the UK?

    Summary: South Africa has been plagued by corru...
  • The NHS and a Web of Deceit.

    Summary: the NHS and our social care services a...
  • Don’t Conflate Brexit with Party Politics.

    Summary: Brexit is not a party political issue....
  • Labour Must Rethink Its Brexit Strategy.

    Summary: Labour’s policy on Brexit is far...
  • A Tsunami is Coming This Way!

    Summary: With unemployment in the UK so low it ...
  • You Need to Balance Your Own Budget but the Government Doesn’t and Shouldn’t.

    Summary: The Tory obsession with reducing the d...
  • The View from Catatonia*: Don’t Talk about the War!

    Summary: The problems within the Tory party are...
  • The Wheels Are Coming off!

    Summary: The Tory party seem to be in advanced ...
  • Labour Must Keep Calm and Leave the Tories To Self-Destruct.

    Summary: There is a big potential danger in the...
  • May-hem In the Housing Market.

    Summary: Theresa May has given a Leader’s speec...
  • Mt Theresa Close to Eruption.

    Summary: A dreadful eruption is close! Mt Teres...
  • Songs from the Viper’s Nest.

    Summary: The Tory party are in total disarray a...
  • Boris and His Bucket Bomb.

    Summary: Boris has again lumbered into view to ...
  • Why Allowing the Henry VIII Provisions to Pass Would Be a Disaster.

    Summary: The Great Repeal Bill relies extensive...
  • Another Folly for Fallon!

    Summary: The movie “Dunkirk” showed how easy it...
  • Might Northern Ireland Trigger Another British General Election?

    Summary: The politics of Northern Ireland are c...
  • Summer Is Over: Back to the Salt Mine.

    Summary: Summer is over with little prospect of...
  • A Spot of Serious Collateral Damage?

    Summary: The war of words between the US and No...
  • Can Jeremy Corbyn Walk Upon the Water?

    Summary: There is a big potential danger in the...
  • Fallon’s Folly

    Operations room in HMS Queen Elizabeth. Summary...
  • Dealing with the Brexit Fraud.

    It doesn’t matter how Brexiteers spin thi...
  • Solving The Housing Crisis: A Fairer Deal For All

    Summary: Successive governments have been gross...
  • Democratic Lies.

    Summary: We are told repeatedly that the refere...
  • Where Next for Labour?

    Summary: The Labour promise to end austerity an...
  • Under the Shade of the Magic Money Tree.

    Summary: The Tories criticism of the Labour man...
  • Paying for Social Care Or Anything Else. Simply the wrong question!

    Summary: We must stop conflating expenditure in...
  • Time for Labour to Park Its Tanks on Theresa’s Lawn!

    Summary: Brexit is going to happen and Labour a...
  • Theresa May: Exposed As a Fraud

    Summary: Theresa May wants us to believe she is...
  • Theresa May: Weak, Unstable and Now Unsafe.

    Summary: Theresa May wants to be seen as a lead...
  • Its Even Worse Than You Realise, Teresa!

    Summary: The figures for those needing care und...
  • Raising Money from the Elderly, Not from the Rich.

    Theresa May’s new manifesto will force el...
  • Parliamentary Reports Side-lined By Snap Election.

    Summary: reports of Parliamentary Committees ar...
  • We Need to Talk about Theresa.

    Summary: The real Theresa May is very different...
  • Winning Your Seat for Labour.

    The game is on, and you need to win back your s...
  • Outline Radical Centre-Left Budget: Revision 1.

    Summary: This is intended to be a strawman budg...
  • Defence in the 21st-Century.

    Summary: The UK military is very poorly equippe...
  • Time for a new political party?

    Summary: the increasing dissatisfaction with th...
  • Fighting Brexit: Sowing Doubt amongst Brexiteers

    Summary: Fighting Brexit is something that must...
  • The Labour Brand Is Becoming Irredeemably Toxic. What Can We Do Now?

    Summary: The Labour Party is widely agreed to b...
  • Britain Defenceless in the 21st-Century.

    Summary: The British defence programme is in an...
  • Fair Access to the British Justice System.

    Summary: The British legal system is in a state...
  • Rethinking the British Prison System: Reducing the Population

    Summary: The UK prison system is in crisis with...
  • Extreme Right Group Work for Brexit Breakdown

    Summary: The prospects for a rapid breakdown in...
  • British Higher Education System Failing the Young and the UK.

    Summary: It costs much more to go to university...
  • Extraordinary New Cult Discovered In UK!

    Summary: a strange new cult, the BeLeavers, has...
  • Government Driving up Non-EU Immigration Intentionally.

    Summary: The cost of training nurses that is pr...
  • Brexit Plan for Labour Agreed at Last!

      Summary: There is a comprehensive new proposa...
  • Brexiteers in Fantasyland: Trade Deals Much Harder Than They Imagine.

    Summary: There is a great deal of naivety about...
  • Please Can We Have Better Leaders?

       Summary: The last few days have been extraor...
  • The Naked Empress Theresa.

    Summary: The latest interview with Theresa May ...
  • Brexit Fraud Unravelling

    Summary: The government are being told by their...
  • Brexit: Opportunity for the Biggest Right-Wing Power Grab for a Generation.

    Summary: If Brexit does go ahead a vast array o...
  • Brexit – A Guide to a Dangerous Future: book review by Colin Gordon

         https://www.canburypress.com/…/Brexit-What...
  • Massive Negligence by Theresa May when Home Secretary.

    Summary: The rules that define the permitted ex...
  • Brexiting in an Earthquake Zone.

    Summary: the route towards Brexit is much more ...
  • Trump Success Should Stimulate Labour Refocus.

    Summary: what has happened in the US and what h...
  • Trade Agreements with EU Virtually Impossible.

    Summary: The rejection of CETA by the regional ...
  • Fair Taxation On Corporate Profits (Rev3).

    Summary: Multinational corporations have too ma...
  • A Brexit Plan for Labour

    Summary: Theresa May in Birmingham claims the C...
  • Labour’s Elephant in the Room: Immigration

    Summary: Labour needs to articulate its policie...
  • Austerity Madness Curable at Last

    Summary: The economics underpinning the drive f...
  • Fair Taxation On Corporate Profits.

    Summary: Multinational corporations have too ma...
  • Tackling Inequality: Making Britain Fairer For All

    Summary: The gross inequalities in British weal...
  • Neoliberalism: A Beginners Guide.

    Summary: The word “neoliberalism” i...
  • Divine Right of Labour MPs

    Summary: Labour MPs need to make a serious effo...
  • Hinkley Point C: Can We Trust China?

    Image: Proposed Chinese Reactor Design. Summary...
  • Hinkley Point Reactor: Doesn’t Work and Isn’t Safe.

    Summary: the reactor design for Hinkley point C...

Please follow & like us :)

Follow by Email
Twitter
Follow
Google+
http://outsidethebubble.net/2017/01/23/trident-the-third-way-make-do-and-mend-2
Facebook
Get new posts by email:
  • Home
  • Latest Posts
  • Archive
  • Useful Links
  • About
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use

© 2016 All rights reserved. Outsidethebubble.net

TOP

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)

  • Follow by Email
  • Twitter
    Follow
  • Google+
    http://outsidethebubble.net/2017/01/23/trident-the-third-way-make-do-and-mend-2
  • Facebook